The dollar's value against major currencies has fallen in recent months as the U.S. fiscal outlook worsened and amid expectations that interest rates will remain close to zero for some time to fight the economic downturn.
This week, the euro broke above the psychologically important level of $1.50 driving gold prices to record levels, prompting many global central banks intervening on currency markets to slow the dollars fall. (Fig. 1)
How Did We Get Here?
Since the financial crisis last fall, currency markets have taken their cues mostly from stock markets. When stocks plunged in March of this year, investors rushed to the safety of U.S. government bonds, pushing the dollar index up to 89.62, the highest point this year.
Since then, however, it has been a steady downward drift for the greenback. As markets steadied into a rally, traders sold Treasuries and Dollars for riskier assets and higher returns, pushing the dollar lower against other major currencies.
The value of the euro has risen by 79% in nine years since euro hit 0.84 in Oct. 2000 (Fig. 2), and the White House has done little to curb the dollar's slide during this period. Loose monetary policy and a weak U.S. dollar are part of the consequences resulting from the U.S. recent trends of unprecedented spending, fiscal deficits, and accumulations of government debt.
“Strong Dollar Policy”…Not
Although the current Administration officially supports a strong dollar, the latest indications came from Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke and Larry Summers, President Obama’s chief economic advisor.
Mr. Bernanke said this week that the U.S. should cut down on its budget deficit and increase the savings rate in order to reduce global imbalances. Bernanke’s statement chimed with that by Summers earlier this year, when Summers said that
World War III - Currency
“the rebuilt American economy must be more export-oriented and less consumption-oriented… and less oriented to income growth that disproportionately favors a very small share of the population."
There are only so many paths you can take to be “more export-oriented”, and at the same time save more/spend less. We could increase our savings rate; however, with the unemployment rate around 10%, it is certainly a challenge, to say the least, for middle class Americans. Therefore, the most likely options are
- Devaluation of the dollar to help exports
- Slapping taxes on imports; or
- A national sales tax or a value-added tax (VAT), which seems to have gained traction in Washington, to discourage spending and fund federal deficits.
Tails, Dollar Loses
There have been increased signs recently that central banks and governments in many parts of the world may gradually end the massive quantitative easing programs. Australia, for instance, hiked rates to 3.25% and highlighting inflation concerns. The U.S. Federal Reserve, on the other hand, has shown little indication that it is anywhere close to removing the massive liquidity injected into the system.
In fact, last Tuesday, San Francisco Federal Reserve President Janet Yellen said she doesn't expect the central bank to tighten monetary policy “in the next few months.” This suggests the U.S. will stay on its current course of stratospheric fiscal deficits, zero interest rates, easy money, and… a weak dollar in the near term. Worse yet, in a recovering world, any good news about growth could provoke dollar selling.
Double Dip, Hyperinflation or Both?
A weaker dollar would be beneficial to exporters and to the balance of payments with a narrowing trade deficit as imports would fall faster than exports. So, with domestic demand depressed from the recession, a short to medium term boost to exports could be good for the US.
However, the flip side is that the diminishing purchasing power of the dollar will inevitably drive up prices for goods and services, among other long term effects. This could only result in three likely scenarios manifesting by the end of next year:
- W-shaped double dip recession as higher prices crimp recovery
- Hyperinflation, if we have a stronger than expected economic growth
- Another plausible scenario is that the U.S. could lapse into a double-dip recession with high inflation in commodities, i.e., a stagflation scenario.
Dollar Status Intact, For Now
The U.S. remains the largest economy in the world. The absence of a credible alternative to the dollar, means that, despite its declining value, its status as the world’s reserve currency is not seriously under threat. In addition, the complexity, geopolitical realities would arguably rule out the re-pricing of oil in non-dollar currencies at this time. All that might change in the future, but it will be a very long, long (think decades) debate.
Strategy: Anti-Dollar & Anti-Inflation
Meanwhile, the dollar will continue to weaken as interest rates in many countries and the eurozone are higher than the current rock-bottom U.S. rates, providing currency traders carry-trade opportunities. This will encourage more selling of the dollar and buying up stocks, commodities and other currencies, which has been the general trend since spring.
So, based on the discussion so far, prudent investors should allocate a portion of their portfolios to hard assets like silver, agri products, and non-dollar currencies such as Brazil’s Real (BRL) or the Australian Dollar (AUD) to hedge against inflation risk and the US Dollar`s devaluation.
Note: This is our view of the dollar and its potential impact in comparison to the opinions of Mr. Peter Schiff also posted on this blog.